I've been going through a serious Matthew Good phase lately.
I've mentioned "Anti-Pop" and Avalanche previously, but I'll admit that I hadn't really taken the chance to listen to the older Matthew Good Band material. I'd even stumbled across the US version of Beautiful Midnight in the bargain bin at Media Play, but hadn't really given it much of a chance.
As much as I loved Avalanche, and after hearing two songs off of his new album, I decided to order it (and Audio of Being) off of his official site (since it's only available in Canada).
White Light Rock & Roll Review (or Revue, depending on if the picture on his site is the "new" spelling of the album) is a rather sparse-sounding album. Good decided to "go back to the basics" and record his band playing live rather than record each instrument separately. He also limited the use of overdubs to vocals and minor guitar parts, which is a complete 180 from Avalanche, which has layers and layers of instrumentation.
On some songs, the spartan sound doesn't help. For me, the lead guitar part in "Little Terror" is so forward that it sounds out of place.
But when the album works, it's amazing. Lead single "Alert Status Red" is a highlight, as is the more acoustic "Empty Road". But my hands-down fave is "Buffalo Seven", which has an unbelievably catchy guitar part during the pre-chorus.
While working through the new album, I also found myself spinning Beautful Midnight. It's often cited as Good's best album, and now I can understand why. It's loaded with really great rock songs like "Load Me Up", "The Future Is X-Rated", and "Jenni's Song".
<mini-rant>
For the album's US release, Atlantic decided to replace a few songs with three songs from MGB's previous album Underdogs. Now, don't get me wrong, I love those songs. Some of the regulars say that their inclusion ruins the flow of the album, but they work for me, granted that I have yet to hear the songs they replaced.
But Atlantic also decided to bring in Chris Lord-Alge to remix them. I stumbled over a copy of Underdogs last week, and can again confirm my opinion that Chris Lord-Alge is one of the worst mixers in the business. While I like certain aspects of his remixes, the guy cannot mix drums. He makes snares sound like cardboard. With rock records, I love a good explosive snare (see: Nevermind), and this guy supplies the exact opposite.
I've hated his mixes in the past, but getting to hear how these songs sounded before he got his hands on them makes for a unique perspective. As I see it, they sounded a lot better before.
</mini-rant>
Next stop: MGB's Audio of Being